Monday, 5 October 2009

Diary Under Review

Well a few weeks ago I said I'd purchased a student diary to see what it was like and report back on its usability. The Stella Cottrell Student Planner 2009-10 is part of the well established and respected Palgrave Study Skills series. After years of using standard academic diaries, I thought it would be interesting to see how the student counterpart compared. And this is my verdict.


On the Plus side:
  1. The week by week layout is nice. Each day organises your input into 'time, activity, where and to do today'. This simple method has been really useful for standardising my information and making it less confusing.
  2. The ability to number each week. I don't usually have this, but the student planner leaves space for you to add the week number at the top of each week spread. This is handy when lectures are often referred to in week numbers.
  3. The tip of the week: This makes is a student facing document and you're sure to benefit from at least a few of the tips.
  4. Bank Holiday listings. Useful because you don't always know when bank holidays fall when you're a student.
  5. Tutor contact details. A very good idea for keeping that key information in one place ready for future and impromptu usage.
  6. Revision Timetable. Very useful if you need a framework to work with. And again, keeps everything in the same place.
  7. Its general 'studentness'. As you would expect, lots of extras for students including an extensive range of student related websites with generous spaces to also add your own. Lots of student tips and easy access information to things like time management. And finally, some relevant yet less expected information such as Word and PowerPoint short cuts, London underground map and an apostrophe guide.

On the down side:

  1. The Year Planner. It is fine really but I much much prefer a vertical over a horizontal layout. Maybe this is something I'll just get used to but oh how I do miss the traditional way...
  2. The position of the Year Planner. It should be the first page but its not, its the second. This doesn't sound like a big deal but I am so used to being able to access it immediately rather than thumbing through pages clumsily.
  3. The lack of a ribbon. You know, the ones that mark the page you're on. The planner does have an alternative, its a plastic ruler that clips into the ring binders. It works fine but does mean you have to unclip and clip back in each week - a bit of a faff really.
  4. Its flimsy. Rather than a hardback, its covers are plastic. Hmmm, will it stand the test of time (and use). I'm really not sure.
  5. It doesn't an overlap. Which meant that in August I had to improvise with a bit of randmly printed out bits of paper. This will matter less for students though, as it does follow the summer months at the other end.
So there we have it. Its more good than bad and of course my 'bad' isn't necessarily other peoples 'bad'. Generally speaking, I don't think you can go too wrong with this book if you are looking for an academic diary. It does everything it needs to but also really caters for its niche student market. If you can live with the clippy ruler thing and can forego hardback casing, this diary will certainly do you right.

No comments: